You do what YOU want.
An option does give him equitable interest, and is a great option when a licensed agent is attempting to flip property in another state without a local license …or simply creating an equitable interest for himself in the event he’s selling someone else’s property in another state.
An option makes the buyer a principal to the transaction. It also keeps you honest, because now, you can’t sell to ‘anyone’ without this other guy’s cooperation.
That is, unless there’s some agreement that excludes buyers YOU bring to the table.
Frankly, I would NOT do an option. Either the guy has a buyer, or he doesn’t. The best I would do would be to carve out any buyers he brings to the table, from buying from me in the future without him getting a referral fee.
However, I’m not putting myself in a position where he controls my deals with an option. Really? Forget that.
I’m supposing he wants to record the option, too, am I right?
That’d be pretty slick. Then not only does he make sure he controls your deal, but you must get his cooperation regardless of who the buyer happens to be.
What happens if he records his option, and then gets into a car accident, and turns into a vegetable? Just asking.
Well, you get to spend months and thousands of dollars removing his lien. And let’s say you only had a contract to buy, and now you can’t sell the house ‘at all.’
Now you’ve got an angry seller with a freshly-minted lien on his house, and you can’t perform.
What a mess. All because you gave some guy an option on your deal(s).
Again, that’s a very valuable approach if/when you’re buying/flipping houses, and wanting to create an equitable interest for yourself.
Getting an option, rather than a contract to buy, is just as powerful as if you had a sale contract you wanted to assign. In fact, it gives you the same power and control as if you opened escrow in a conventional sale, and then assigned the contract.
In this case, with this other guy… nah.
“Equitable interest” doesn’t require having an option. It could just be an agreement to refer “x” buyer to “x” property (or more than one “x”).
As long as YOU have an equitable interest, you can include this guy with a simple referral agreement.
If I were to guess, this guy is a little too sophisticated for anyone’s taste …or a flake.