Paul, I think you read more into my comments than was there. Nothing says you can’t continue investing while you are paying off your mortgage. If you are investing now, and still have discretionary income left over at the end of the month, that money can be directed to debt reduction on your primary residence. Paying your mortgage loan off in ten years does not preclude you from investing – especially if your investing uses the creative techniques that don’t require any money out of your pocket.
Mine don’t anymore. My investing has always followed a traditional rental property investment approach of buy with 80% financing (or less) and hold for production of income indefinitely. Today, My properties are self-sustaining. I refinance my properties to leverage equity to purchase more properties. Sometimes I use a 1031 exchange if the exchange will upgrade my portfolio, increase my cash flow, and increase my net worth. I don’t contribute my own money to support my investments, instead, I use new debt and the income from my investments to make more money to reinvest.
The point I was trying to make is that most of us have a 30 year mortgage on our homes. My monthly mortgage payment is $854 for just the principal and interest. I will have that mortgage payment for 30 years unless I pay off the note sooner (I am in my retirement home and have no intentions of moving). What if I paid off my home in ten years instead of 30 years, without increasing my monthly expenses? That is 240 monthly mortgage payments I won’t have to make – 240 payments total $204960. That is $204960 more money available for me to invest for 20 years that I would not have if I used those 20 years to make the mortgage payment on my primary residence.
If you have an investment that can return a greater return than what you're paying on your home loan, and assuming the risk is commensurate with that return, then why wait? Why not deploy that capital now?
As a general statement, I completely agree.
My mortgage rate is only 4.5% and logically I should direct discretionary income to other higher yielding investments. That I had been doing and have created a stock portfolio that yields around 10% in current income. My portfolio is well diversified with 30 securities and has a position value in the low six-figures. The portfolio income can be used to increase my positions or acquire additional securities. The stock market portfolio is self-supporting and creating new wealth every day without adding any additional capital out of my own pocket.
My epiphany came last year. In July 06, I had a triple bypass. I had no symptoms and no risk factors for heart disease other than being a male over 50 years of age, a little overweight, and not exercising. I went to the doctor for an unrelated problem and my wife tells the doctor that I had not had a physical in ten years. The doctor says, “We like to get a stress test for men your age,” and he scheduled it. Everyone was surprised that I flunked it, even the doctor.
While I was on the operating table for the bypass surgery, the doctors discovered an undiagnosed cancer. I finished the radiation and chemotherapy this past November. As a result of the cancer treatment, I had to be put on a feeding tube to assist nutrition. I came off the feeding tube this past April.
All of these life events were surprises, but they got me to thinking about my own mortality. If I were to die tomorrow, my personal income stops. My wife will have to use all of her monthly pension and social security income to make the mortgage payment and maintain the house. My wife is disabled and does not drive. All the income from the rental property and stock investments would be needed to replace me with a housekeeper, cook, chauffer, and a home health care nurse. If an unplanned expense came up, my wife would have to sell something. Everything that gets sold reduces the monthly cash flow available for her living expenses. How much simpler it would be if my wife owned the primary home free and clear and had all of her income available to meet her lifestyle needs.
Paul, I would consider myself financially independent. Nine years ago, at the age of 49, our net worth was well into seven figures, and we had enough unearned income to support our retirement lifestyle, so my wife and I both left the W2 world for the leisure of retirement. This did not mean that we quit investing either. As a matter of fact, with more time to devote to my investment “hobby” our net worth has doubled in the past nine years. My wife is not actively engaged in our investments, but instead leaves it all to me. My concern is that if I were to die after 2010, my wife’s cost of living would increase dramatically. I am only seeking to minimize the financial impact of my passing by giving my wife a free and clear primary residence.
If I can pay off my mortage in less than ten years without effectively increasing my monthly expenses, then I want to look closely at the program. If a $500 software application can help me do that, I will seriously consider the purchase.