If I understand the numbers…this is what it looks like to me:
$135,000 ARV
<$ 10,000> Less Repairs
<$ 13,500> Less Marketing/Agency/Closing Costs
<$ 72,000> Less Loan Balance
$ 39,500 Equals Gross Profit
<$ 19,750> Less 50/50 Profit Split
<$ 19,750> Equals Profit Split
190% Managing Partner’s Annual COC Return
There’s so many details to think about here, but try to make it as simple as possible, despite the fact that you’re getting in bed with a seller you don’t know. I mean this is like marrying someone for their money…in a strong sense.
I would rather take title, give the seller a $19,750, no interest note, secured solely against the house, payable upon sale of the house.
This means I “gurantee” the seller a fixed, sure profit, assume all the overhead and carrying costs, but I also don’t have to pass everything I do by an amateur seller, w/wo an emotional attachment to the house itself, whom might also second-guess my every decision.
Of course guaranteeing the seller a fixed profit, assuming all the risks of a sale, is worth ‘something’ more than just the equivalent of half the profits. So, maybe $15k to the seller, and the remaining $$ to you, is fair.
The deal looks great on paper, but the devil’s in the emergent details.
So, I would rather get the deed, and give the seller a note. Much, much cleaner deal.