There are always things that can be done differently, or better, that will change the outcome of a particular type of situation.
For instance, first, you need to change your way of thinking. Is not, how can you persuade them to sell their house to you, it should be, they have to convince me to buy their house from them.
The principle is still the same, but do you see the fundamental differences in those statements? In the former, you are the one motivated. You’re trying to buy their house. In the latter, they have to “persuade” you, or to convince you, that their house is the property that you should buy.
Also, if you’re getting enough information on your call to actually make an offer (subject to inspection, of course), then make one. All you really need to know is the location, # of beds, baths, heated sq ft, estimated repair costs, and estimated value (all from seller). Depending on your particular investing style, you may need more, or different info, but a cash buyer only needs those.
With that info, you can say, “well, based off your numbers, I could offer you X amount cash, and we can close in as little as X days. Would you like to have this sold by then?”
That may or may not get you a deal, but it will determine fast their motivation level and if you really do need to setup an appointment to discuss further options.
And Doc is right on the money. You have to make you offer better than the others, though it isn’t always about the money. At least, not the more, the better. Sometimes, a fast closing is more important than more money later. Sometimes, a higher price is more important even if they have to wait for years to get it. Every seller’s motivation is different. It’s up to you to determine that motivation and decide which you want to work.
Raj