John,
Have you even read the police report? If you did, you’ll see that Gates started on his “you’re a racist cop” and “you don’t know who you’re messing with” rant inside his house, and Sgt. Crowley was GOING TO LEAVE despite it… Gates then took it outside, refused to calm down after being asked more than once, a small crowd was gathering, and he was ranting and challenging their authority… when Gates took it outside, it was no longer just his rights…
You’ll note NONE of the neighbors INCLUDING the one who called it in have come forward to support Gates’ side of the story or to say the cops were out of line… if that were the case, I think we all can agree it would be ALL OVER THE NEWS… the fact that it isn’t should tell you something…
“Disorderly conduct is very rarely an appropriate charge outside one’s home. Disorderly conduct charges are used by cops as a way of arresting people who have offended them and they use the charge to show such audacious citizens who the boss really is.”
You asked what law was broken… you are given the law, which as you can see from the above post fits PERFECTLY to the situation (see the arrest report also), and all I can see is you finding excuses for Gates… As I said, disorderly conduct is usually dropped, and used to keep the peace…
“Police may use a disorderly conduct charge to keep the peace when a person is behaving in a disruptive manner, but presents no serious public danger.”
Like I said, if you don’t like it, campaign against it, but it is a law until then…
“Who were the police protecting and what were they serving by arresting this man?”
The community… Gates was NOT arrested in his house, it was when Gates took it outside, and CONTINUED to be non-compliant with HIS actions and disturbing the peace in the process, that he was arrested on disorderly conduct…
“These officers misused their badge and arrested an innocent man.”
I think Crowley said it best when he said that Gates “controlled the outcome”… So the White, Black (you know the one who “supported the arrest 100%”, but ALSO supported how Crowley handled it), and Hispanic officer (who wrote the OTHER police report corroberating the events), along with the others present, were all wrong and Gates was right??? To say that the police misused their badge after Gates was non-compliant MULTIPLE times in addition to his racial ranting (no accountability there, BTW) is just ludicrous…
These were veteran police officers, not rookies…
If they allowed ALL citizens to behave like this, without consequence, they would ultimately put themselves in danger by weakening their authority…
You should also consider that once all the details came to light, and that there was a recording available that the police were considering making public, Gates all of a sudden was no longer looking for an apology OR going after a lawsuit… extremely telliing, considering Gates (you know “you don’t know who you’re messing with”) is Obama’s friend…