Or…Maybe you should closely examine the NUMBERS!!!
How do you explain the BILLIONS IN PROFITS the big 3 made during the SUV boom. The UNIONS had the same benefits then…Hell, they had MORE benefits THEN. They’ve now given back many of those benefits. But…even WITH THEM…It had NO BEARING on Ford, GM or Chryslers ability to generate MASSIVE PROFITS for their share holders. In 1999 Fords stock was at $36/share and the company was making more than $1 BILLION every QUARTER!!!
If the UNIONS are the reason U.S. car companies don’t make money, how do you explain this???
http://www.nytimes.com/1999/01/22/business/company-reports-ford-reports-stronger-than-expected-earnings.html
So much for your “NO MONEY LEFT” theory.
MULTIPLE points I outlined in my post are in this article. From Fords TRUCK and SUV profits to the RIDICULUS decision by MANAGEMENT to purchase a car company (Volvo) that they would eventually lose BILLIONS ON!!! It would seem that YOU might be MISDIRECTED in your understanding of the complete situation here.
The Unions bear their share of the blame, no doubt about that. But if Ford could make over $1 BILLION profit in SINGLE QUARTER in 1999 WITH those very UNIONS…SOMETHING ELSE CHANGED. THAT was the big 3’s complete LACK of investment in their PRODUCT. They had MORE than enough money. They CHOSE not to.
You can blame who ever you want…The REALITY is the BIG 3 Management did more to screw up these companies than ANY UNION ever could. That is a FACT.
The UNIONS didn’t instruct Ford to buy JAGUAR, or LAND ROVER or ASTON MARTIN or VOLVO…Every single one of those businesses LOST BILLIONS of FORD’s $$$$$$$…That wasn’t the UNIONS FAULT. It was the absolute STUPIDITY OF MANAGEMENT that caused this. Ford eventually sold EVERYONE of those companies at HUGE LOSSES!!! That’s AFTER they pumped BILLIONS and BILLIONS into each of them for DECADES. (Ford is expected to announce the sale of Volvo at any time… FOR $4 BILLION LESS THAN THEY PAID!!!)
It is estimated that with the Jaguar/Land Rover purchase ALONE…Ford LOST $35 -$50 B I L L I O N in CAPITAL!!!
There’s your R&D money Pal!!! BOAT LOADS OF IT!!! Add the 1999 profits mentioned in the article above to the BILLIONS they BLEW On Jaguar & Land Rover and the TOTAL CASH Ford could have been sitting on would have been UNBEATABLE for any other company!!!
Don’t believe it???
http://blogs.thecarconnection.com/marty-blog/1015368_just-how-much-did-ford-lose-on-jaguar-and-land-rover
Show me how the Union takes the blame for that complete disaster. LITERALLY BILLIONS and BILLIONS of dollars were WASTED buying DIEING CAR COMPANIES. Imagine the vehicles FORD could have NOW if those BILLIONS were spent the way TOYOTA spent their PROFITS. This was a COMPLETE FAILURE OF MANAGEMENT!!! NOT UNIONS…MANAGEMENT!!!
In the article I referenced it mentions Fords bid for Volvo…Well they were the HIGH bidder!!! They paid $6,000,000,000 (Thats $6 BILLION) for Volvo.
Then they spent TENS OF BILLIONS revamping Volvos entire line up…RESULTS???
They’ll be LUCKY to get $2 billion for it now (Fords estimate NOT mine) and Volvo hasn’t turned a profit in YEARS.
The UNIONS had NOTHING to do with these decisions. They came STRAIGHT from some of the most inept managers to every set foot in Fords Headquarters.
Now the pendulum is begininning to swing the other way. Unions have made HUGE and HISTORIC concessions. The management currently running Ford HAS CAUGHT TOYOTA and HONDA in quality. That comes directly from CONSUMER REPORTS, not from me. Those UNIONS assemble cars just as the NON UNION Japanese companies workers do. So it’s obvious that being in a UNION isn’t affecting their ability to produce QUALITY CARS.
Like I said…You can blame anyone you want…I blame George Bush for EVERYTHING THAT GOES WRONG ON THIS PLANET!!! In my opinion he was THE WORST PRESIDENT THIS COUNTRY HAS EVER HAD or WILL EVER HAVE…and HE ALONE is responsible for the REPUBLICAN PARTY getting their @SSES handed to them in the election!!!
That’s who I BLAME…But that doesn’t mean I’m RIGHT!!!
You can blame anyone you want for the current situation…Again…It won’t mean your right. But…UNDERSTANDING what REALLY went wrong can give you EXTREMELY VALUABLE INSIGHT into the changes currently being made at these companies and the AFFECTS those changes will bring in the future.
Like…
ALAN MULLALY’s decision to sell EVERY SINGLE ONE of those CR@P companies they OVER PAID for in the 1990’s. Here’s an example of excellent management. Here’s some more…
His decision to obtain CREDIT when credit was available 2 years ago. He took a BEATING for this in the press. Now he looks like a genius.
His decision to go from 26 power train varients to 7 (like TOYOTA does) Lower cost, fewer parts, MORE MONEY available to IMPROVE those 7 drive trains in the future. Again…a page DIRECTLY out of the TOYOTA play book.
His decision to model Fords Engineering Division on the TOYOTA model. At TOYOTA mechanics at dealerships are REQUIRED to notify the FACTORY of ANY issues they see with a system or part on Toyota vehcles. These reports are sent IMMEDITAELY to Engineering and those systems are either fixed or REDESIGNED at the COMPONENT LEVEL or the supplier level. This drastically lowers the number of cars that get assembled with FAULTY components. This is EXACTLY how Ford has caught Toyota on QUALITY.
It HAS come FULL CIRCLE…That Lamp sitting on the Japanese executives table is now it’s a TOYOTA STARTER that sits on FORD Engineering Dept table!!!
And Yes…That’s EXACTLY how one goes UP as the other goes DOWN!!!