I agree with you on this if you really believe 4.74 was what you would get. I’m of the belief that returns in this area on rent are higher because my belief is expenses in this area (due to higher rental values) are less than 45%. (More in the 25% area). So my return before appreciation would be higher than most CD rates. At the same time, my real return would increase after expense right-offs.
Keep in mind, for tying up that money, my lowest return would be around 4.74%. Upside would be tied to appreciation in a top 20 fastest growing county in the nation.
I would talk to active investors in your area and ask them about their real world expenses - make sure you take into account everything that would affect your cash flow. Additionally, I would make sure to do a thorough due diligence on expenses for any property I was considering.
My S&P was at 12%+ last year and my wife’s international fund was up near 20%. If you want a real mover (with alot of risk) check out latin american index funds, china indexes, or india indexes…